Should You Sell Spam Links On Your Blog?
Wednesday, February 13th, 2008Would you recognize a spam link if you saw it? They’re not that hard to notice really. I can spot one from a mile away.
Typically, bloggers who write blogs for popular search terms will receive an e-mail that goes something like this:
Hi,
Thanks for replying. I am interested in permanent placement of paragraphs on specific pages of your website. Paragraphs will be custom written and according to the content of your site.
So, I can offer you: USD 15 for each of the following pages.
This is a verbatim message I received from a spam link buyer for a website that I personally own. Below these paragraphs were a set of links to the pages this link buyer wanted to place his links on followed by, in case I couldn’t do the math, a total that he would pay for those links. I found it interesting that three of those links were for pages that I wouldn’t consider selling links for under any circumstances no matter what the price - I figured that would be obvious by the content.
- The first page was to my e-zine opt-in page. Now why would any idiot sell links on a page where he wants to take opt-ins for his newsletter? That would defeat the entire purpose for that page. And the spam link buyer wanted his links on that page permanently. Yeah, I’m a moron. NOT!
- The second page was a sales letter for a book that I wrote. This is a no-brainer. What used car salesman is going to take $50 to tell every customer he meets, “Go across the street; they sell more cars than we do?” Again, do I have Stupid written all over my website? Nope. Hit the next guy, Chump!
- The third page the spam link buyer wanted me to pimp out was to a book review page. This is a page I use to write book reviews for books I like. After I praise or trash the book, I tell my readers where they can go to purchase the book. Obviously, the desired result is that they will purchase the books. Though I don’t make any money on some of them, there are books that I review where I get a commission from each sale because I’m a member of an affiliate program. Why would I lead potential customers to another website for a one-time sale?
Because this brave spam link buyer was batting .500, which isn’t bad for a major leaguer, I decided to offer him the courtesy of a response. So I told him under what circumstances I’d consider selling a link. (I really have no problem selling links, but I HAVE A BIG PROBLEM with selling spam links, as you will soon see).
My response to the Mr. Spam Link Buyer went like this:
William,
I appreciate your offer, but there are several problems with the way you have presented this. No. 1, links on three of those pages are not for sell at all. A careful review of the (Page 1), (Page 2), and (Page 3) pages will show that it would be counterproductive for me to sell links on those pages.
Secondly, I believe I could sell links on my website for much more than $15 permanent placement. It is likely that I could get $5-$10 per month per page on those pages for the right website. Then you would have to be clear about what the benefits are that you are paying for. If you are looking for PageRank transference, it is out of the question. Links would have to be nofollow links. The traffic alone would be worth it to you.
Thirdly, the links on your pages look spammy (he had the nerve to include examples of what he was talking about with his paid link scheme). I won’t involve myself in that at all. I don’t encourage more than one link per paragraph in most online content and I only link out from my website if there is a clear value to my visitors in me doing so. I would have to evaluate the content on the pages you want to link to in order to see if it would provide any value to my readers.
Finally, I would feel more comfortable with the arrangement if you provided me your anchor text and let me write the content. If I like the pages you are linking to then I will write the content to encourage my visitors to link to your site. If I don’t like it then the deal is off. I won’t recommend something just to make a dollar. I have over 20 years writing experience including academic writing, journalism, sales material, and I currently work full-time as an Internet marketer, blog ghostwriter, article writer, and SEO content writer so I can back up what I say.
Alternatively, if you want to work something out for my (deleted) blog at (deleted) then I might be more amenable to that. The price would be less there because it doesn’t have the same level of traffic as the website. But some of the same demands would be in place (though I’ll be more flexible in certain ways). Again, if I like your content then I can
offer you other benefits. But if I wouldn’t freely link to your content without you paying for it then I likely wouldn’t link to it if you do pay. That’s how I see paid link value and if you are still interested then let me know what pages you want me to link to and your anchor text then we’ll go from there.
I thought that was pretty straightforward and doggone clear. Mr. Spam Link Buyer, however, didn’t respond to any of the points. Instead, he simply responded
Hi,
Thanks for your reply. I can adjust the travel keyword link vacations with informative and non spammy links, if you think you can go ahead with this just let me know.
In other words, he wanted to put travel links on my non-travel related website. Why?
The idea behind paid links is to get additional traffic and inbound links with PageRank value (though Google frowns on the practice for the purpose of PR value). I think traffic value is a lot better than PR value even if you have a PR of 8 or 9. If your PR is that high then you probably have lots of traffic as well. But that’s why I won’t sell links for PR. I will sell them for traffic. But that is a digression.
In order to make paid links work to their best advantage for you and for your customer, the links should be to a site that is relevant in terms of content. In other words, travel sites should link to travel sites, real estate sites to real estate sites, etc. Why put travel links on your real estate site? Unless the travel site you are linking to is local to you and provides real benefit to your website visitors it just doesn’t make sense.
If a reader can go to your website and tell a marked difference in the tone, voice, quality of writing, and subject matter from one paragraph to another on the same page then you have a credibility problem. How much is it worth to you to ruin your credibility? Well, that’s what spam links do for you.




